Social Media Update : Social media’s age limits won’t protect your kids

Social Media Update

Social Media Update : The real problem is the apps’ addictive features and how they prey on developing brains

social media age limits aren’t a foolproof way to keep your kids safe online. Here’s why:

  • Easy to Bypass: Age restrictions are often based on self-reported information. Savvy kids can easily create fake accounts with older birthdates.
  • Focus on Age, Not Maturity: Not all 13-year-olds are equally mature, and some younger kids might be more responsible online than some teenagers. Age limits don’t account for this individuality.
  • Underlying Issues Remain: Social media platforms themselves can be designed in ways that promote negative habits or expose users to harmful content. Age limits don’t address these design issues. Social Media Update

So, what can you do as a parent? Here are some alternative strategies:

  • Open Communication: Talk openly with your kids about social media. Discuss the potential dangers, like cyberbullying or inappropriate content. Encourage them to come to you with any concerns.
  • Privacy Settings: Help your kids adjust their privacy settings to limit who can see their posts and information.
  • Gradual Introduction: Consider delaying unrestricted social media access until your child reaches a certain level of maturity.
  • Co-watch and Discuss: Spend time together exploring social media platforms. Discuss what they see and the types of interactions they have online.
  • Parental Controls: Utilize parental control features offered by some platforms or consider parental control apps to monitor and restrict online activity.
  • Positive Alternatives: Encourage your children to explore other online activities that are more age-appropriate and can foster positive development. Social Media Update

Remember, age limits are just one piece of the puzzle. By combining open communication, responsible tech habits, and parental guidance, you can equip your kids to navigate the online world safely and constructively.

Momentum has been building to force social media companies to make their products safer for kids. But some of the solutions getting the most attention, while well intended, don’t address the underlying problem: the way these apps prey on developing brains. Social Media Update

A new report from the American Psychological Association highlights solutions that follow the science. That’s an important message for policymakers, parents and the companies themselves. Because if we want to see meaningful improvements, we need to focus on what’s actually causing the harm. That’s not necessarily the age of children on social media — the focus of many current policy efforts — but the products’ features, and how those features affect young minds. Social Media Update

As the APA report points out, the teen brain is still learning skills like impulse control, planning and prioritization. That makes them especially vulnerable to the infinite scroll or the pull of followers, “likes” and “shares.” And some are particularly susceptible to harmful content or bad actors. Social Media Update

The brief list of recommendations from the APA follows its social media advisory from last year, which demanded better science about how platforms like TikTok and Instagram affect kids’ brains. But some of the responses from policymakers and thought leaders were not always aligned with the science, says Mitch Prinstein, the APA’s chief science officer. Too much of the policy focus narrowed to a simple idea: age limits.Social Media Update

But drawing a bright line on age is not a cure-all. Turning 13 (or for that matter, 16) does not make someone magically capable of handling the responsibilities of social media. Conversely, some children might have the maturity to navigate those platforms before they are 13. Social Media Update

Moreover, the age limits we already have aren’t working. Tweens and teens are notoriously more tech-savvy than their parents. They excel at finding workarounds to age restrictions on apps and time limits on devices.

“There aren’t simple solutions to a complex problem,” says Dave Anderson, a clinical psychologist at the Child Mind Institute. Social media isn’t going anywhere, and teens are going to use it. “We need to tailor our solutions to the risks [identified by] the science, rather than the risks amplified by the zeitgeist,” he says. Social Media Update

What could that look like? Prinstein offered a template for safer social media accounts that sounded pretty good to this parent of a tween. “I would love to enter my child’s age and have all of the guardrails automatically put into place,” he says. The default would be to protect a child’s data, turn off the endless scroll, disable likes, and bar certain types of sensitive content (things like cyberhate, explicit content or posts that encourage eating disorders). Those settings could be tweaked for more mature children. “It doesn’t seem like a lot to ask,” he adds. Social Media Update

Age limits alone are too blunt a solution. Yes, policy makers have always needed to make somewhat arbitrary choices about when kids are ready for certain responsibilities, whether that’s driving a car or accessing Snapchat. But some kids can benefit from access to social media. And yet solutions to its inherent faults have focused on banning access altogether or putting the onus on parents to muddle through. Social Media Update

As I’ve written before, parents play an essential role in their children’s transition into a healthy digital life. But even the most diligent parents can’t navigate this environment alone. We need social media companies to step up — not in the form of token changes, but with substantive modifications to their platforms that address what the science shows is a problem.

Another thing that social media companies need to do: Share their data on how kids are using their platforms. Progress towards real transparency feels frustratingly slow. Earlier this year, the Center for Open Science announced a partnership with Meta to facilitate certain researchers to access data that could help them better understand the relationship between social media and well-being. That’s a start, if a small one. Social Media Update

Companies could accelerate this research into the ways social media is used by and affecting kids. They could offer up data from experiments they have already run on how to engage teens with their products. Surely they know a lot about which features make their products even more problematic for teens. They should disclose them and fix them.

If we focus on the easiest fixes rather than the more nuanced solutions indicated by the science, nothing will change. Social media companies only seem interested in doing just enough to keep their CEO out of the Congressional hot seat. Lawmakers seem interested only in symbolic political victories. Parents need to keep advocating for real reform. Social Media Update

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *